Skip to content
Pop Culture

Sarah Michelle Gellar Reveals Family Connection with Freddie Prinze Jr.

Abigail Renee Abigail Renee | November 22, 2026 | 3 min read

Sarah Michelle Gellar and Freddie Prinze Jr. have been married since 2002, and it turns out their families were neighbors long before that. Speaking to E! News on Friday, November 21, the actress said an Ancestry search showed their grandparents once lived within walking distance of each other in the Bronx.

Gellar, 49, said their grandparents lived “less than two miles away from each other in the Bronx.”

She added that they could have known each other.

Sarah Michelle Gellar and Prinze Jr. Discover Family Ties Through Ancestry

Gellar told E! News the couple had a running joke for years. Their only overlap, as far as they knew, was that she briefly attended the same high school as Prinze Jr.’s father. She described it as their one shared thing, the small coincidence they kept bringing up.

Ancestry gave them a bigger one. Gellar called the discovery kind of crazy, and she’s right. Two families, one borough, a couple of miles apart. Decades later their grandchildren met on a horror movie set in North Carolina.

The Couple’s Unique Connection Goes Back to the Bronx

Geography is what makes the find so strange. Gellar is a New York native. Prinze Jr. was born in Los Angeles and raised in New Mexico, about as far from the Bronx as an American childhood gets. Us Weekly pointed out that his late father, comedian Freddie Prinze, was originally from New York, which is where the family line doubles back.

Stories like this land differently for a long-married couple than for a new one. Twenty-plus years in, most couples think they know every chapter of each other’s history. Then a database turns up a street map nobody had looked at, and the marriage suddenly has a prologue.

Nothing about it changes their life. Nobody’s grandparents are confirmed to have met. But Sarah Michelle Gellar and Prinze Jr. now have a second origin story, one that predates both of them, and that is the kind of thing a couple tells at dinner parties for the next twenty years.

Sarah Michelle Gellar Reveals Family Connection with Freddie Prinze Jr.
Image: DepositPhotos

How Their Relationship Started with Friendship and Barbecues

Their own beginning was slower than the Ancestry twist. The pair met filming 1997’s I Know What You Did Last Summer, and romance did not come first. Prinze Jr. told Us Weekly in April 2020 that Gellar couldn’t drive at the time, so he drove her the hour between Southport and Wilmington. Those drives were where they became friends, talking about life and what he called their completely different philosophies.

Food did the rest. By the end of the shoot, Prinze Jr. said, he wanted to cook for her because that was what his family did. He and his cousins started a weekly barbecue at her house for her and her friends.

Friendship first, family-style cooking second, wedding in 2002. They later reunited onscreen in Scooby-Doo that same year and in its 2004 sequel.

Sarah Michelle Gellar posed with her daughter Charlotte at the People and InStyle Drive-By Party in Las Vegas. She told People her husband was elsewhere that weekend, at their son’s race. The couple share two children.

Nobody yet knows whether two sets of grandparents in the Bronx ever crossed paths.

Sources: Us Weekly, Page Six


Leave a Comment
Join the conversation — your thoughts matter

Abigail Renee
Written by
Abigail Renee

Abigail Renee is a New York–based writer who covers celebrity relationships, weddings and breakups for Relationship Rules. With a background in psychology and more than five years writing about love and modern dating, she brings a candid, thoughtful eye to the stories behind the headlines, and believes honest conversation is the foundation of any real connection. When she isn't writing, she's trying new restaurants, listening to Coldplay, or rewatching her favourite 2000s sitcoms.