Yes, they’re together, and they’re married now. Andrew Shue and Marilee Fiebig married at their farm outside of Stockton, New Jersey on Sunday, November 1. They got there after nearly three years together, and the wedding happened just days after Andrew said in an interview that the two of them had quietly gotten engaged earlier in the year. Many readers know them as the exes of former GMA anchors Amy Robach and T.J. Holmes. They waited out that public mess and ended up with a quiet happy ending of their own.
2010: Two Weddings, Two Other Spouses
This story begins with other marriages. Back in 2010, Robach married actor Andrew Shue, while Holmes married Fiebig that same year. Marilee is an immigration attorney. She and Holmes have a daughter, Sabine. Andrew has three adult sons with his first wife, Jennifer Hageney, whom he was married to from 1994 to 2008.
December 2016: Friends Through “Our GMA Family”
The two couples knew each other socially. In December 2016, Fiebig shared a selfie alongside Shue on Instagram, and in the caption she said she “loved hanging out with our GMA family.” The next year, the four appeared together in a photo from Shue’s birthday party alongside other ABC colleagues, including Michael Strahan and Sara Haines.
November 2022: The Scandal Breaks
Andrew and Marilee found themselves thrust into the spotlight in November 2022 when news broke that their respective spouses — GMA co-hosts Amy and T.J — had been having an affair. Robach and Holmes have insisted they were already separated from their respective spouses when they started dating.
December 2022 – March 2023: The Divorces
Holmes filed for divorce from Fiebig in December 2022. In January 2023, Marilee’s attorney said her focus remained on her daughter and that the divorce was moving forward privately and as amicably as possible. Andrew Shue and Amy Robach completed their divorce in March 2023. Marilee’s divorce from Holmes was finalized in December 2023.
Mid-2023: Friendship Turns Into Romance
According to sources who spoke to Entertainment Tonight, Shue and Fiebig had started dating six months earlier, around the middle of 2023. One source said they “bonded over the trauma from their respective break ups”. Andrew later described it this way to People: they were sharing themselves “in a time where we both needed a friend.”
December 2023: The News Goes Public
Page Six reported the relationship, claiming Shue and Fiebig have been together around six months. Us confirmed in December 2023 that Andrew is dating Fiebig. Their source said the two were “happy together” and that it was more than a “rebound.” That insider also said Marilee was “willing to move on and let go of the anger” she felt toward Holmes.
February 2024: “Going Strong”
The couple kept quiet, but a source told PEOPLE in February that they were still “going strong” two months after news of their relationship went public. The source added that Marilee “seems really happy with him.”
Summer 2024: PDA in NYC, and Amy’s Blessing
About six months after the news broke, the couple was spotted packing on the PDA in New York City. Around then, a source told Us in July that “Amy is happy for Andrew and Marilee.”
August 2024: Elisabeth Shue Says He’s “Very, Very Happy”
Andrew’s sister, the actress Elisabeth Shue, gave a rare update at the Aug. 13 premiere of The Good Half. She told E! News that her brother was “very, very happy.” Andrew said much the same: “I am very happy, my kids are all great, and I’m working on a project.”
December 2024: A Red-Carpet Night Out
They showed up as a couple at the 2024 Grassroot Soccer World AIDS Day Gala at Hall Des Lumieres on December 03, 2024 in New York City. Soccer runs deep for Andrew, who played soccer professionally for several years.
Early 2025: Moving In Together
Next they started sharing a home. They began living together, in early 2025. Us Weekly said the pair was taking their relationship slow, focusing on enjoying each other’s company after their previous marriages ended.
Spring 2026: A Secret Engagement
Shue and Fiebig got engaged in spring 2026, he confirmed to People. They kept news of the milestone a secret for several months before sharing with the world. In the meantime, their exes kept making news. Holmes and Amy Robach married on September 19 in Arkansas.
October 21, 2026: “There’s a Happy Ending”
Andrew confirmed to People on October 21, 2026, that they were engaged. “We’re very grateful and hopeful,” he said. “I don’t know how it happened, but there’s a happy ending.” He also talked about what he learned from his past. Shue has said he accepted his own part in a marriage not working out, and he added that “the magic of love is when you go from a need to giving.”
November 1, 2026: The Farm Wedding
The ceremony took place on the couple’s 92-acre property outside Stockton, N.J., before a small group of relatives and close friends. Marilee wore an off-the-shoulder white lace gown with a matching shawl and a netted veil. Shue, who is 59, wore a black suit. Her 13-year-old daughter Sabine, whom she shares with T.J. Holmes, stood with her. Elisabeth Shue was among the guests. The wedding took place 11 days after Shue disclosed the engagement in an interview.
Where They Stand Now
As of November 2026, Andrew and Marilee are newlyweds. They’re blending his three grown sons and her teenage daughter, and they share a farm in New Jersey. They’ve said very little in public along the way, and Shue has not released additional public comments on the wedding itself. One Page Six source summed up the relationship by saying their connection “turned into something else” and is “bigger than the affair now.” Their exes married first, but these two found their own happy ending.
Sources: Yahoo/Just Jared Jr., Soap Central, BuzzFeed, HollywoodLife, StyleCaster, Entertainment Now, Fox News, Us Weekly via Yahoo, TV Insider, TMZ
